Fantasy Baseball internet radio by Jeff Erickson


In about 45 minutes I’ll be on Jeff Erickson’s Fantasy Focus radio show, on I’ll let you guess what we’re going to talk about. If you get here late, the program is also a podcast, which should live on forever. Classic.

Here’s the show:

We had decided to talk about wonky subjects, which was fine by me. I’m resistent to the whole “who’s your best sleeper” approach to the radio. I have a few elaborations.

In NL and AL only leagues position scarcity gets figured in if you properly price your players using the proper pool. That is, you give everyone their relative price and you find that you only have 10 positive values for catchers, and you need 24/26. You delete all the other players with positive and negative values who aren’t catchers, until the 24/26 catchers are in your pool, and then reallocate the money, making the last catcher worth a buck. Catchers alone don’t get all the benefit of scarcity.

The same holds true in Mixed Leagues, but there are two differences. It’s much harder to draw the line at the bottom, so it’s a little haphazard who makes the draft list and who doesn’t when the catchers are added. And, mixed league prices aren’t linear, so the best players get paid more for being reliable and better than the abundantly replaceable players in the middle and bottom. So the best catchers’ prices go up because they’re the best, period, as well as because they’re catchers. I’m not sure how you would go about quantifying this. I guess aggregated real world results compared to linear prices would get you part way.

As to rules, I don’t have a dog in any rules fight. I think players should play a game that satisfies them and makes them happy. It’s fine if you want to promote dump trading, and it is equally fine to squelch it. I discuss different rules and wrinkles with an eye to solving problems people are having in their leagues, which doesn’t make them happy.

The sleepers I wrote down before the show were Cincinnati’s Ramon Ramirez and the Cardinals’ Joe Mather. You can find more at

1 thought on “Fantasy Baseball internet radio by Jeff Erickson”

  1. Good stuff.

    I try to treat rules questions the same way over at my blog. My league plays with more liberal dumping rules than Peter’s ADL, but we’ve been in business since 1987 and haven’t seen much turnover since 1999 (when the owners who left primarily left because we tightened the rules on dumping at that point). The key isn’t the “right” or the “wrong” rules, but making sure you have a core of owners who are a) happy with the rules you have and b) understand that you can’t have a pissing contest about every little wrinkle in the rules. This is a fun game, not a Congressional subcommittee or a Sunday morning round table on the pros and cons of government spending.

Comments are closed.